Looking at the board, it looks like the middle tone lug should have continuity with the switch lug on the right (component side up) - which makes sense with the direction of the switch bat. I wasn't getting any continuity so I reflowed the solder there and boom! Pedal now works. Sorry about that. I should have figured that out before I posted. And, how sad is it that I had to reflow the solder on my reflow job.
I will say I did completely remove the switches and pots before I started so I could easily get to all the soldering joints.
Thanks again for all the input. You guys are the best.
I'm gonna need y'all on standby - I just bought the Super 8 Looper.